Herefordfootball, yes, it is supposed to be a show of market steers, and they are " supposed' to be judged on their carcass qualities as well as their eye appeal, thickness, lack of excess trim, etc etc. I think where this thing has gone off the rails is that several years ago, so some unknown reason, structural soundness was almost forgotten about. I always find it interesting, that I find more judges forget about structure in the market steer classes, but often will mention soundness issues in the market heifer classes. If a market steer doesn't need to be sound, then why does a market heifer?
In my opinion, it is impossible to judge a market steer show, without a judge giving considerable consideration on carcass qualities, even if they don't mention it in their comments. Yes it is a show, and that is great, but it should be a show of market qualities in a show, rather than just a freak show.
I don't see as many steer shows as most of you do each year, but I have seen many in my days. I agree with many of the placings I see. I could agree more if a little more emphasis was placed on structural issues.
I will always remember the late Joe Lewis, of Alfalfa Lawn Farms, judging the market steers in Denver several years ago. The championship class came out into the ring, and it was an impressive group of steers. In his comments he made special emphasis on the carcass qualities he thought each steer had. One of the steers was being shown by a very attractive girl wearing tight, bright red jeans. At the conclusion of his comments, Joe Lewis said," I am now going to go and slap my Champion steer in today's show. I noticed"her" the moment she walked into the ring." He then walked over and slapped the steer being led by the girl in the red jeans.
I have always said that in a very close class of cattle, the animal being shown by a good looking girl always has a major advantage over a teen age boy. Even if the judge thinks he is being totally fair, the girl will almost always have a physiological advantage. She has even more advantage, if the boy is wearing jeans with the crotch just slightly above his knees. I have seen this happen so often. As they say, perception is 9/10ths of reality.