Show stopper 95 said:
chambero said:
It ain't about how many win a major - it's how many are good enough to make sales. You are splitting hairs to fine if that's all you are judging "good" by.
i was referring to the amount that sell as babies not at the majors-
I knew what you were referring to. I was advising you to not worry about grand overalls, figure out what combinations are raising calves that are making the sale.
I used a bunch of Heat Wave over the years and never really got diddledy. I would stick a toe in that water before I jumped in all the way. HW x char combinations worked a few years ago till better, more consistent things came along. In my opinion, your heifer will need something that creates a little more balance and smoothness. She's got all the "umph" you could ever need. That ain't Heat Wave. The calving ease and cripple problems associated with Heat Wave is getting corrected with his descendants. As good as he was, it was a real issue with him. Much less so with his sons and grandsons. Contrary what so many people like to pretend, the club calf bull business is moving forward.
Sires I know of that are working on Char cows:
Solid Gold is getting it done on PBs. If you want highest probability combination, this might be the way to go.
He has his faults, but Walks Alone is infinitely more consistent than Heat Wave for me. Might not smooth that cow up enough. BIM is smoother, but don't personally know what he's doing on PB Char cows.
There are more than a few really good Smokin Bob calves out there this spring out of PB cows - mostly HooDoos. I bought one. We'll know more a year from now on how they turn out.
Final advice - are you going to try to sell baby show steers or show them? Your first reaction is that it shouldn't matter, but it very much does. Calves that are good enough to win a major are accidents. You won't make money and stay in the game by waiting for an accident to happen. You stay in it by raising good calves consistently that can be sold, and then just get lucky every once in a while for a true ringer. Long term, worry about making your average calf as good as possible.