I think everybody in the world who knows me knows that I am the biggest Tom Brady fan there is, with that said Manning is a close 2nd for me. They will always be compared to each other and Manning has a lot of the records but that has to do with 3 more seasons played. The difference is going to be when Brady plays for 3-5 more years because of Kraft, Bellichick, and Scarnecchia ( until now that he left). They never gave Brady the Toys Payton had in a way. He did have Moss and he has Gronk, but guys like Deion Branch, Edleman, and Welker he created. Bellichick and Scarnecchia focused so much on teaching and coaching other players that his offensive line has always allowed Tom to be Tom Terrific. If you look at Manning especially now, they have so much money invested in Talib, the Wares, Miller, etc that the results is his offensive line. I do not know who is retreating faster, Manning or the O-Line. He has always faced this too, thats why injuries have finally caught up to him. He did always have Jeff Saturday, but thats one, it takes 4 others. He is playing with Thomas now at TE who is a receiving threat but is a blocking liablity. Where as Gronk is an old-school time TE who can do it all. Brady hates to be hit so bad he will duck at Ghosts. Go ahead and make fun but it has him 3 rings and 5 apperances doing it a long with the highest winning percentage ever. I will always believe the main thing that seperates them will be the coaching and playing of the offensive lines. I love watching both of them and i will hate the day either retires, but I do feel Manning should've retired last year with the regular season he had. Hindsight is 20/20 but i agree if he continues he will be remembered has "back in his prime". Just like i feel if Tom wins the Super Bowl this year even if he has 3-5 years left, he should retire a winner and not chase the 5th ring. My personal opinion is i do believe the colts still should have stuck with Manning instead of Luck ( I know nobody knew his status etc) and luck is supposed to be the 2nd coming, but its a win now league and they couldve won more with Manning I believe. Everybody has their own opinion. Colts thought he was done, Elway thought different, both ends ended up making good choices. I just hate to see Manning in the position he is in now. Personally I believe Broncos should've signed Blount in the spring as well, but hindsight is 20/20, nobody knew Ball would get hurt. Both are class act QB's and the league needs about 15-16 more QB's who conduct theirselves the same way.