E6 Durhams said:
Seems to me that Grants sale has a sale average that would put him right there with Saskvalley and Muridale sale averages. I didn’t crunch true numbers. Generally speaking is all I’m saying. I see lots of saskvalley and muridale genetucs being used down here. Almost every big “commercial” type sale here has offspring of genetics from sask and Muri. Studer, JSF, Bar N, Leveldale, BSG, Paint Valley, all have used those genetics heavily. I’ve never seen an HC bull being plugged in lately. Seems to me the HC cattle could be a nice outcross to those other ranches but you never see it in any of their pedigrees. I could be wrong. The JT Trans X bull must of done some good. That’s a outfit that sells in Grants sale. I see lots of criss cross from the saskvalley and Muri programs. Similar environments maybe. I’ve never been to either place. Never seen JIT’s cows. Done lots of deals with XBAR and have some of his cattle here now. He had a bull calf hand picked for me. He didn’t like how the calf was developing so he sent me a different bull. His opinion on bulls and his experience shouldn’t be looked upon as an attack on somebody. It’s reality. Grant has a good thing going with his embryos and semen sales. He does good at the shows up there. Can’t say he hasn’t done his share of winning up there. Can’t begrudge a mans success. I think the disconnect comes when another post comes up claiming a world beater of a bull with minimal evidence to back it up. If I pay 16k for a bull and somebody offers me 16k for half soon after, it’s a ridiculous business decision to say no. Ridiculous. Unless it’s a personal beef I can’t see why somebody would say no. How many shorthorn bulls have sold 16k in semen? Offspring? That list isn’t very long compared to angus. I’ve seen angus bulls bring 18,500 at a local sale in Ohio! Never seen a shorthorn bull bring more than 3500 at anything smaller than a beef expo. I don’t know if any outfit here that sells every bull they have for sale. Maybe some do. I just don’t know of any.
I agree with you in regards to Cruiser's buyers deciding not to sell a half interest for what they paid for him. That was their decision and I had no part in it. I was not involved in Cruiser other than I had collected a few straws of semen when he was a year old. When the man that bought him died suddenly, his wife asked me if I would winter a set of replacement heifers for her. She offered me a half interest in Cruiser to do this. I accepted her offer and I am glad I did. I would love to use some bulls that you have mentioned here, but very few Americans collect Canadian qualified semen.
I have not pursued the US market for several years, and Touchdown is the last bull I had at Cattle Visions. I still get quarterly checks from them for sales. I prefer to sell semen myself, only because it gives me a connection with the people who are using my bulls. I have semen stored at Hawkeye Breeders and I have my bulls listed on our website and I still seem to sell a nice quantity each year. I also have semen from 8-10 bulls in Australia, and I sell far more semen there than I ever thought of selling in the US. Like I said earlier, my customers are basically commercial producers, but I have a few sales each year to purebred breeders. My top bull in 2015 was $32,000 and another at $14,000. Cruiser was the top bull in 2016 at $16,500. Last year, my top bull was $11,000. Last year I had commercial buyers pay $9000, $8000 and two at $7000 and these are prices I can certainly live off. When I started my ET program, it didn't make much sense to me, to do the same thing as everyone else was doing. I have used some American breeding but I don't chase it. I don't particularly try to produce show cattle which is what most everyone else seems to try to do. The UK and Australia are my biggest embryo markets with several hundred embryos sold to the UK each year. Australia has been close but the wicked drought has slowed that market down some. I still am selling embryos down there though. I am doing things differently than lots of others do. The fact that since I started in this ET deal, as a way to get to genetics to the US when BSE hit Canada, I have sold over 2400 embryos to 14 countries is something I never imagined would happen. I think it proves that there is a definite interest in Shorthorn embryos around the world. I predict that the Far East countries like Viet Nam, and Mongolia could be the next big market that shows up. Both these countries have been buying thousands of doses of Red Angus semen in Canada in recent years. I recently had a Mongolian government official meet with me, and he is very interested in Shorthorn genetics some time in the future.