TMJ, that's ok... we all are 'young' at heart...
While I do not doubt for one moment that JPJ is any, and everyone's 2nd high seller... Now, is that the owners' fault-- NO-- it should commend them for doing the job of promoting him.
I'll also admit that he does briing SOME things to the breed, and industry that are needs with moderation, c.e., fleshing abiltiy, and clean genome.. Is he the savior-- most def not! I think what he's also bringing in as side effects are going to be far worse than the positives.. With his shear structural size, or a lack of... and his actual structural flexability that has been breeding on are SERIOUS problems... for any herd, any color... It's not the way to be, as most shorthorn breeders are doing.. by breeding extremes to extremes and hoping to meet in the middle... breeders and reproducers need to be breeding for middle with middle type cattle.. I had a breeder descibe to me once that his program was geared to "create small or at largest moderate framed...bla bla bla cattle... And to them- JPJ wasn't a contender to reside in the semen tank becuase of his lack of performance. They even disliked him enough not to want to use a son, who by the way is a really really good rip- and fit every category in terms of qualifications- but becasue he was a JPJ son, they didn't want him.
Another thing that is a guineune concern of mine is his spoken 'outcross' pedigree- which is more like an 'old' pedigree with leader 21, and more unknown cattle, etc... I think these older genetics can and are being used in today's world very succesfully- like they should be- but I beleive they should be used on a very limited basis-- by only those elite core of seedstock breeders who knew them, and know about them. There was a reason that those genetics were in the yesteryears. Most breeders of today, like myself, know nothing of these oldies, other than what's in black and white, and sometimes color- and by what's said from an old timers mouth. I beleive that most breeders like to shoot the shit.. and more times than not- don't remember those cattle as they were- just in relevance to what they were like. Some times, I don't think outcross (or less popular) is always a good thing. I know that certain bloodlines got popular for a reason because they work!
Even in my own herd, of which I try to remain outcross- I would more classify it as being not popular, and old school like in pedigree. But I am an exception. I only know of the old stuff by what is, and was told to me, and by what I read. I know this saying contridicts itself.. The reason I try to remain unpopular on paper is the endless opportunities of mating possibilities. That's it! The cattle I have were affordable, they get the job done, and to me pedigree means nothing... To me, popular prefixes mean nothing, if they can't get the job done- I refuse to buy just because of a few letters on paper. If my cattle are doing what they should be, and are doing those things great- I could care less what people think of my pedigrees. I also just know that when I lay eyes upon the best beast to walk this planet- I'm going to breed everything I have to him- regardless of pedigree. It will be a plus to have cattle that are unrelated! Most programs can't say that! even though I don't mind linebreeding.
Now, will I ever use JPJ- no, will I use a son? maybe- I've thought about trying Capiche out on heifers, as I really like his bottom side with Mission in there- but what I know, and have heard- that is a double shot of straight- especially upfront... Straight from Kerry's mouth! I like Capiche in Denver, but that was one of my faults on him. Thought he rolled, and was a nickle straight upfront!
On the other note, I hope the J3 cattle people take very little offense to my comments... Their not completely directed at you... I just know that if I'm going to take the time, money, and effort to promote a product- whether cattle, semen, or etc... I'm going to take many pictures, videos, and use technology to the fullest extent to promote my product to a wider variety of potential customers. I'm going to take pics at weaning, for those who concern on feeder calves, I'm going to picture at the other stages of life as well-- for those who worry about them. I'm going to take pictures in fitted outfits- for those who show, slick sheard for those who slick- and of course I'm going to take working pics for those who are serious contenders. Any Joe Blow can critize my product all they want- if they have the back up to do it- but I'm going to do my darndest to prove them wrong.. and likely, It'll just bring me free advertising... Just as I have done with JPJ!
jody kabat
kf-acres