I've used both and I much prefer Luster's. It's a lot lighter and the can doesn't spray as aggressively so it's a lot harder to apply too much product. I don't use it daily but in the winter I'll use it about every second day because it helps to relax the curls and waves that we're often fighting with Hereford hair. I do like Pink Oil for showday but like I said it's a bit heavy so it's easy to apply too much. Both products will give the hair lots of pop after being worked in with a comb and blower.