Sammmy said:
I am curious why no one has recommended just a 50/50 mix of gluten and soybean hull pellets for what is apparently just a calf? The price for that has ranged from $125 a ton delivered and now is up to 175 a ton delivered. Works well enough for calves of all sizes on a commercial basis. We use it for creep feed and backgrounding on pasture. To me for just growing out a steer that is not going to be shown until next summer, as in a county fair steer, why not feed him this way and then a few months before the show perhaps put him on the high dollar ration. I would seriously doubt that the end result would be one bit different as opposed to feeding the $300 a ton stuff all the way.
Re-read my post & you will see that I mentioned using "by products"... and Corn Gluten Feed & Soy Hulls specifically.
Too much CGF can potentially cause some trouble with sulphur levels... 50% may not cause problems, but I'd rather play it safe. My dad has had success with 1/3 CGF & 2/3 S.H. with mineral, yeast & rumensin added. They call that mix "calf creep feed" & bigger frame cattle will gain over 3.5 per day on it. Not sure what it costs bulk, but 50 lb. bags are $9.20 or so right now. As they get older, you can have them add hominy to it to make the calf fatter. Due to cheaper costs & the convenience factor, my dad finished a couple of his steers on (I think) 60% Hominy with CGF & S.H mixed. Or you could add corn instead of the hominy... the mill here only deals with by products, so they wont add corn, but you could do it yourself, especially if you are hand feeding. Bobwire's 3-3-3 mix would work too, but you probably will still have to add more energy (hominy or corn) to turn it into a finisher.
It takes common sense to make it work, but again, it's hard to beat plain shell corn & good grass hay or mostly grass hay, IMHO. Usually, it's as cheap as anything & it will fatten them nicely. $5-$6 or so per 50 lbs. of corn & $3-$3.50 for 75 lbs. of hay. You just can't beat that price when trying to add typically more expensive ingredients like oats, cotton seed hulls, substituting cracked corn, etc. Research has shown that younger calves typically gain more weight on whole shell corn over cracked or ground. With older cattle, it's just the opposite, but we've had good success finishing cattle on shell corn. Again, more grass hay & less corn= grower. More corn & less hay = finisher. You could add a little protein supplement too, especially in the grower stage, but if the hay is pretty good and/or if it has a little clover mixed in, you may not have to. It's really that simple & it's really easy to transition from grower to finisher. Obviously, they need salt, mineral & water too. You could add roughage from other sources (beet pulp, cotton seed hulls, etc.), but hay @ $3-$3.50 per 75 lbs. is usually quite a bit cheaper than 40-50 lb. bags of beet pulp or cotton seed hulls. Besides hay, there are other cheap roughage sources, but you better know what you are doing, so I wont go there on a public message board, although a good nutritionist could give you some ideas. Anyway, this obviously isn't a show calf, so why not go the cheapest route & what is cheaper than shell corn & hay?