rmbcows said:
If you can clone bulls from frozen semen, and I'm not 100% sure you can, why hasn't anyone cloned some of the old greats? If you have semen in the tank from an old deceased bull, and for discussions sake, let's say the owner is deceased also, would it be legal to have that bull cloned? Provided of course you had a bucket of money you wanted to spend.
I had to think about this overnight and remind myself what the original question was.
If we could clone from Great Old Bull semen, would that take us in the "wrong direction".
No. As knabe points out, a restart could give us the advantage of hindsight and we could avoid many dysfunctional traits that have been the consequence of selection for extremes.
My general belief in the utility of locally adapted strains of cattle that can be out crossed to other locally adapted strains could benefit from such a restart.
As tall cool says, ET seems to serve the same purpose if we use old semen with functionality hard wired in on a population of eggs collected from a cow that carries the environmental programming we aspire to restart in.
This could work, especially in small herds managed by very observant and experienced breeders.
Without a breeders eye for functionality and commitment to maintaining the strain, I don't see how the genes would remain confined.
My reservations are purely superstitious. By using 50 year old genetics in my program, such as it is, and being naive to the business, I have the benefit of all kinds of un-messed up characteristics, which I take for granted because it's all I know. BUT, every time I attempt to double up on the old stuff I head into pudville. So how far back is far enough?
My best results have come from mixing that gene pool with the Galloway gene pool, which has been maintained by common sense, stubbornness and frugality. Within those parameters anything can work.