I appreciate having someone around to play the devils advocate - there's nothing wrong with asking someone to defend the things they post, especially when they do so repeatedly and adamantly. It makes us think a little harder, look a little closer at the things we say and the way we say 'em, make's us have to see there's always another side. I don't even mind seeing a thread you know is gonna get a little heated - keeps things interesting, as long as it's not directly stepping on someone else's toes (or their cattle). But there's got to be a line somewhere - every thread about cattle can't be turned into one about TH, every thread about anything else can't be turned into "you're a dirty, sorry, low bred steer jock so your opinion counts for less than nothing".
I hated it then, and I hate it now, but I've gotta quote my old high school English teacher here - "If I give you an inch and you take a mile, I'm going to take your inch away".