XBAR, you are a straight shooter and I appreciate that.
It's hard to move on from Roan Gaunlet, but I have to agree with you when I really look at the animals.
It would be a fine thing if Shorthorn breeders, through linebreeding AND selection, developed strains of Prepotent maternal trait bulls that some in the Angus breed have developed. Then we could cross the strains commercially. Probably this is going on and I just don't know about it.
Best example I know of for breeding for maternal traits:
http://shoshoneangus.homestead.com/home.html
When I select the bulls I use, I visualize their five to ten generation pedigrees as a pen of cattle. In an ideal pen, the cows in the pen would be more similiar to the preferred type. Of course, the same cow appears in the pen several times among the more inbred stock. Since the bulls are simply the progenitors for the maternal characteristics, their indivdual performance is secondary. While I have flirted with a few of the more extreme bulls within the population, I have finally learned to avoid them altogether. Larry Leonhardt
The body of the highly fertile cow is in beautiful proportion; she looks feminine or broody. Her brisket is not full and she has a dewlap running around her brisket. She has a tremendous stomach capacity, is big from the hip to the pin and from the hipbone to the patella or stifle joint.The largest part of a fertile cow`s body is the midrib region. Standing behind such a cow, her midrib or spring of rib is the widest part of her body, not the thurls or hipbones. The influence of sex hormones on hair growth and hair shedding of cows is most important. Fertile cows are sleek and glossy.
Jan Bonsma, Judging Cattle For Functional Efficiency
I know these are Angus models, but the principles are the same. This is a good discussion and it would be great to see more Shorthorn examples.