knabe said:Ag. professing to be capitalistic, but then, not.
Get rid of ag subsidies.
Subsidies too high.
Iowa corn subsidies ridiculous.
More corn from less land so land can be used for something else or nothing.
https://weather.com/news/news/2019-04-05-corn-air-pollution-deaths
knabe said:I apologize for having a degree in agronomy and for growing corn and other crops in Kansas and California. Other similar information is probably irrelevant as well.
Thanks for being a fan. Your use of the old saying use is an incorrect application. You only implicated yourself.
In reality, your employ of the straw man attack was decent. Sort of Bernie Sanders like.
I know. Triggering right? Sorry about that.
WinterSpringsFarm said:knabe said:I apologize for having a degree in agronomy and for growing corn and other crops in Kansas and California. Other similar information is probably irrelevant as well.
Thanks for being a fan. Your use of the old saying use is an incorrect application. You only implicated yourself.
In reality, your employ of the straw man attack was decent. Sort of Bernie Sanders like.
I know. Triggering right? Sorry about that.
Other than telling us how much you think you know, because of the degree and all. How about you answer my questions? How many acres of corn have you grown in Kansas and California? I figure it has to be thousands upon thousands of acres....cause those 2 states are so well known for it. And just curious how did you grow it and what were the yields?
Have you or do you make a living off of corn? And once again what kind of land use would you feel is better for than the environment?
I'll talk about growing corn....and other row crops all day long, and I don't have a degree. You see making a living doing it day in and day out tends to teach you a few things those universities don't. So am I triggered by your comments...sure. But love having discussions with people like yourself.
And for the record, yes take away the subsidies. It would sort the men from the boys IMO. But let's not just remove it from farming, lets remove them all.
knabe said:bless your heart.
i'm sure there are plenty of topics using your logic you have no right to comment on but do so endlessly. ELABORATE ON A "RIGHT TO COMMENT"-iS THIS GAINED BY: ACADEMIC PROWESS,A POLITICAL AFFILIATION, OR CASH AND CARRY?
mark tenenbaum said:ELABORATE ON A "RIGHT TO COMMENT"-iS THIS GAINED BY: ACADEMIC PROWESS,A POLITICAL AFFILIATION, OR CASH AND CARRY?
E6 Durhams said:WinterSpringsFarm said:knabe said:I apologize for having a degree in agronomy and for growing corn and other crops in Kansas and California. Other similar information is probably irrelevant as well.
Thanks for being a fan. Your use of the old saying use is an incorrect application. You only implicated yourself.
In reality, your employ of the straw man attack was decent. Sort of Bernie Sanders like.
I know. Triggering right? Sorry about that.
Other than telling us how much you think you know, because of the degree and all. How about you answer my questions? How many acres of corn have you grown in Kansas and California? I figure it has to be thousands upon thousands of acres....cause those 2 states are so well known for it. And just curious how did you grow it and what were the yields?
Have you or do you make a living off of corn? And once again what kind of land use would you feel is better for than the environment?
I'll talk about growing corn....and other row crops all day long, and I don't have a degree. You see making a living doing it day in and day out tends to teach you a few things those universities don't. So am I triggered by your comments...sure. But love having discussions with people like yourself.
And for the record, yes take away the subsidies. It would sort the men from the boys IMO. But let's not just remove it from farming, lets remove them all.
I’ll bite. Do you need field tile? Do you graze livestock in a rotation with your grain crops? Do you practice tillage? Corn and bean production have killed rural America’s diversity. Not to mention our health in general. Glyphosate residuals are showing up more and more. Monocultures exist nowhere in nature. How you farm doesn’t separate the men from the boys. It insures future generations a food source. In farming, you are either killing the soil or building it. Which are you?
E6 Durhams said:WinterSpringsFarm said:knabe said:I apologize for having a degree in agronomy and for growing corn and other crops in Kansas and California. Other similar information is probably irrelevant as well.
Thanks for being a fan. Your use of the old saying use is an incorrect application. You only implicated yourself.
In reality, your employ of the straw man attack was decent. Sort of Bernie Sanders like.
I know. Triggering right? Sorry about that.
Other than telling us how much you think you know, because of the degree and all. How about you answer my questions? How many acres of corn have you grown in Kansas and California? I figure it has to be thousands upon thousands of acres....cause those 2 states are so well known for it. And just curious how did you grow it and what were the yields?
Have you or do you make a living off of corn? And once again what kind of land use would you feel is better for than the environment?
I'll talk about growing corn....and other row crops all day long, and I don't have a degree. You see making a living doing it day in and day out tends to teach you a few things those universities don't. So am I triggered by your comments...sure. But love having discussions with people like yourself.
And for the record, yes take away the subsidies. It would sort the men from the boys IMO. But let's not just remove it from farming, lets remove them all.
I’ll bite. Do you need field tile? Do you graze livestock in a rotation with your grain crops? Do you practice tillage? Corn and bean production have killed rural America’s diversity. Not to mention our health in general. Glyphosate residuals are showing up more and more. Monocultures exist nowhere in nature. How you farm doesn’t separate the men from the boys. It insures future generations a food source. In farming, you are either killing the soil or building it. Which are you?
[/quote
Thank you E6. You nailed it. We have lost half the organic matter in our soil in this country. Regenerative agriculture is growing and the direction we need to go.
beebe said:E6 Durhams said:WinterSpringsFarm said:knabe said:I apologize for having a degree in agronomy and for growing corn and other crops in Kansas and California. Other similar information is probably irrelevant as well.
Thanks for being a fan. Your use of the old saying use is an incorrect application. You only implicated yourself.
In reality, your employ of the straw man attack was decent. Sort of Bernie Sanders like.
I know. Triggering right? Sorry about that.
Other than telling us how much you think you know, because of the degree and all. How about you answer my questions? How many acres of corn have you grown in Kansas and California? I figure it has to be thousands upon thousands of acres....cause those 2 states are so well known for it. And just curious how did you grow it and what were the yields?
Have you or do you make a living off of corn? And once again what kind of land use would you feel is better for than the environment?
I'll talk about growing corn....and other row crops all day long, and I don't have a degree. You see making a living doing it day in and day out tends to teach you a few things those universities don't. So am I triggered by your comments...sure. But love having discussions with people like yourself.
And for the record, yes take away the subsidies. It would sort the men from the boys IMO. But let's not just remove it from farming, lets remove them all.
I’ll bite. Do you need field tile? Do you graze livestock in a rotation with your grain crops? Do you practice tillage? Corn and bean production have killed rural America’s diversity. Not to mention our health in general. Glyphosate residuals are showing up more and more. Monocultures exist nowhere in nature. How you farm doesn’t separate the men from the boys. It insures future generations a food source. In farming, you are either killing the soil or building it. Which are you?
[/quote
Thank you E6. You nailed it. We have lost half the organic matter in our soil in this country. Regenerative agriculture is growing and the direction we need to go.
Won't argue that organic matter is great, and that its a real issue. Also wont argue that a corn and bean rotation is bad for soils. And pretty sure I didn't argue that. I think what I stated was take away the subsidies and the real farmers (men) would come out on top because before the subsidies all the things E6 was referring to were practiced, other than no till.
My real argument to Knabe was producing MORE when there is already tons! And then I wanted to hear his alternative land use plans. Which he has dodged several times. In fact I'd love to hear how everyone else is farming and making a living.....not hobby.
WinterSpringsFarm said:E6 Durhams said:WinterSpringsFarm said:knabe said:I apologize for having a degree in agronomy and for growing corn and other crops in Kansas and California. Other similar information is probably irrelevant as well.
Thanks for being a fan. Your use of the old saying use is an incorrect application. You only implicated yourself.
In reality, your employ of the straw man attack was decent. Sort of Bernie Sanders like.
I know. Triggering right? Sorry about that.
Other than telling us how much you think you know, because of the degree and all. How about you answer my questions? How many acres of corn have you grown in Kansas and California? I figure it has to be thousands upon thousands of acres....cause those 2 states are so well known for it. And just curious how did you grow it and what were the yields?
Have you or do you make a living off of corn? And once again what kind of land use would you feel is better for than the environment?
I'll talk about growing corn....and other row crops all day long, and I don't have a degree. You see making a living doing it day in and day out tends to teach you a few things those universities don't. So am I triggered by your comments...sure. But love having discussions with people like yourself.
And for the record, yes take away the subsidies. It would sort the men from the boys IMO. But let's not just remove it from farming, lets remove them all.
I’ll bite. Do you need field tile? Do you graze livestock in a rotation with your grain crops? Do you practice tillage? Corn and bean production have killed rural America’s diversity. Not to mention our health in general. Glyphosate residuals are showing up more and more. Monocultures exist nowhere in nature. How you farm doesn’t separate the men from the boys. It insures future generations a food source. In farming, you are either killing the soil or building it. Which are you?
Do I need field tile- it would be nice, but don't have any
Do I rotate cattle on crop ground- not often, but occasionally
Do I practice tillage- only when necessary
Not sure how you figure either you are killing the soil or building it, please elaborate on that. Also please elaborate on glyphosate residuals, I'm always entertained by these debates. Be sure to give me some university studies too. :
So E6 how do you farm?