Shorty hf bulls

Help Support Steer Planet:

trevorgreycattleco

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 22, 2010
Messages
2,070
Location
Centerburg, Ohio
aj said:
Trev in general I think you are right. However I think in the Shorthorn breed show ring deal you have to have tonner cows to compete. I think the the establishment is scared to death that if the breed decides to downsize they will be on the wrong end of the deal. I think this is why say jpj is badmouthed on here so bad cause he is such a down sizer. I do think a tonner cow can survive anywhere! All it takes is 30#'s of grain aday and 10 ton of alfalfa a year plus all the guru products.
The shorthorn show ring deal is as far from real world as you can get. Show cattle are for the most part hobby cattle and people don't pay attention to the bottom line as closely as a commercial guy because they don't have to.  I prefer the 5 frame cow that weighs between 1,200 and 1,500. IMO those type cattle will produce more profit per acre in my situation. JPJ is the latest attempt to fix a extreme with a extreme. Fire and ice. From now on when I look for females, one of the most important things to me is how they feed them. Do they work for themselves or are they pampered registered cattle.  Fescue is a pretty awesome thing when you learn how to use it and linebred cattle that have worked on it for years are the type I want to build from since I have tons of fescue! :eek: To bring in bulls from a A.I. pimp that are raised totally different than yours will take you backwards. How else can you explain the turnover rates in the AI biz. Promotion, commotion, emotion lead to massive amounts of breeding mistakes. I know I have fallen for it in the past. My bulls being used now are not extreme in any way. The trick is having the guts and vision to use my own stuff for generations to build something better and bring in genetics(when needed) that will compliment not necessarily fix my herd. Sure sounds easy but we know better.
 

feeder duck

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 24, 2007
Messages
603
 Lets call an ace an ace. The Shorthorns are a 98% show ring breed. Until the entire breed grows  chasing the "big money" pedigrees and breeders go back to cutting there own path I am done. I have never been more frustrated by the "bull" in this breed than I am now. I am sure I speak for more than a few. There are some dam good low birth pedigreed cattle out there that will work.  Trying to sell Shorthorn heifers is a political nightmare. Enough Said!!!

 Jeff
 

Okotoks

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 17, 2010
Messages
3,085
sue said:
Hands down the most popular Shorthorn bull in the breed is JPJ. His total registration is close to passing even Trump. I wouldnt mind a piece of the royalties each qu
arter?
It would seem JPJ stamps his offspring. The Reserve Champion at Olds last weekend was aJPJ, JSF Addicted 82U. A good bull with some nice calves but possibly taking a bit too much grow out of the calves in one cross. The Champion was Paintearth Rama 53U by Saskvalley Ramrod 155R. These were both really good bulls but Rama is so complete and impressive. His calves were a nice type but probably a little deeper bodied than Addicted's. Rama's dam goes back to a Gar-lind cow and that for me would be a plus. Gar-lind females seem to produce wherever they go. There are some good females in their upcoming reduction sale!
 

justintime

Well-known member
Joined
May 26, 2007
Messages
4,346
Location
Saskatchewan Canada
feeder duck said:
 Lets call an ace an ace. The Shorthorns are a 98% show ring breed. Until the entire breed grows  chasing the "big money" pedigrees and breeders go back to cutting there own path I am done. I have never been more frustrated by the "bull" in this breed than I am now. I am sure I speak for more than a few. There are some dam good low birth pedigreed cattle out there that will work.  Trying to sell Shorthorn heifers is a political nightmare. Enough Said!!!

 Jeff

Jeff, I have always respected your program, and you have produced some good cattle... and I am sure you still do. Fortunately, there are some places left where Shorthorns are not just a show breed. Here where I live, selling Shorthorns  heifers usually a pretty easy thing. Selling Shorthorn bulls also seems to be growing every year. Personally, I have never been more excited about the future, but I live in a completely different marketplace than you do. I wish for all our sakes, it was different where you are.
 

feeder duck

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 24, 2007
Messages
603
justintime said:
feeder duck said:
 Lets call an ace an ace. The Shorthorns are a 98% show ring breed. Until the entire breed grows  chasing the "big money" pedigrees and breeders go back to cutting there own path I am done. I have never been more frustrated by the "bull" in this breed than I am now. I am sure I speak for more than a few. There are some dam good low birth pedigreed cattle out there that will work.  Trying to sell Shorthorn heifers is a political nightmare. Enough Said!!!

 Jeff

Jeff, I have always respected your program, and you have produced some good cattle... and I am sure you still do. Fortunately, there are some places left where Shorthorns are not just a show breed. Here where I live, selling Shorthorns  heifers usually a pretty easy thing. Selling Shorthorn bulls also seems to be growing every year. Personally, I have never been more excited about the future, but I live in a completely different marketplace than you do. I wish for all our sakes, it was different where you are.

Justintime thank you for the kind words.

I truely believe it is a two fold problem. The economy has not helped. I can also be my own worst enemy. I tend to not try to follow to many trends. I like to do my own thing. I firmly believe there is an absolute need for outcross gentics in the breed. I am not against the show ring obviously, because that is my market. But the pedigrees that are out there are just not my thing. The Shorthorn steer deal is dead. They are so few and far between. I believe in the breed at this time type is dictating pedigree strongly. The dream of huge money as well. I'm not jealous just frustrated at the moment.
As for JPJ is he the answer...probably not the only answer but a good bull none the less. His progeny can be somewhat small and low performing. I AM NOT BASHING THE BULL so everyone relax. I have a Jazz son running with cows as I write this. He is no smaller than our Wild Side bull. However he should have some power as his dam is a D. Vision/Gizmos Image. That is how he fits our program. The dam side offers growth. I have fewer Shorthorns than ever running in our pastures partly economic partly management.We are still in the Shorthorn business as one of the older breeders in Indiana and plan on being here longer than some new big spenders. We have recently started a set of Red Angus females and I LOVE THEM. Disposition is AWESOME. They perform at the feed pan. Lastly as a middle class adult I can afford them. Re world cattle do not cost more than my house.

I know you can not believe everything you are told, but I was recently told a very prominent steer family has $150,000 in three steers. Sorry Its just not that important to me and I have been at it my entire life!

Peace!
Jeff
 

sue

Well-known member
Joined
May 1, 2007
Messages
1,906
... all of the show heifers are in Iowa and sell this weekend??



 

Okotoks

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 17, 2010
Messages
3,085
feeder duck said:
justintime said:
feeder duck said:
 Lets call an ace an ace. The Shorthorns are a 98% show ring breed. Until the entire breed grows  chasing the "big money" pedigrees and breeders go back to cutting there own path I am done. I have never been more frustrated by the "bull" in this breed than I am now. I am sure I speak for more than a few. There are some dam good low birth pedigreed cattle out there that will work.  Trying to sell Shorthorn heifers is a political nightmare. Enough Said!!!

 Jeff
I can understand some breeders frustration as the same genetics that keep winning in the show ring are not always the same that work commercially. I do beleive there are a lot of genetics out there that will work. With the number of breeders that have the same concerns I believe there is a good future if we work together. Few breeds have the focus on the show ring that shorthorns have had. Lots of Angus and Red Angus breeders don't show but have a good commercial market for their bulls. I think we need to collect more info on feed conversion and carcass and get the message out there.

Jeff, I have always respected your program, and you have produced some good cattle... and I am sure you still do. Fortunately, there are some places left where Shorthorns are not just a show breed. Here where I live, selling Shorthorns  heifers usually a pretty easy thing. Selling Shorthorn bulls also seems to be growing every year. Personally, I have never been more excited about the future, but I live in a completely different marketplace than you do. I wish for all our sakes, it was different where you are.

Justintime thank you for the kind words.

I truely believe it is a two fold problem. The economy has not helped. I can also be my own worst enemy. I tend to not try to follow to many trends. I like to do my own thing. I firmly believe there is an absolute need for outcross gentics in the breed. I am not against the show ring obviously, because that is my market. But the pedigrees that are out there are just not my thing. The Shorthorn steer deal is dead. They are so few and far between. I believe in the breed at this time type is dictating pedigree strongly. The dream of huge money as well. I'm not jealous just frustrated at the moment.
As for JPJ is he the answer...probably not the only answer but a good bull none the less. His progeny can be somewhat small and low performing. I AM NOT BASHING THE BULL so everyone relax. I have a Jazz son running with cows as I write this. He is no smaller than our Wild Side bull. However he should have some power as his dam is a D. Vision/Gizmos Image. That is how he fits our program. The dam side offers growth. I have fewer Shorthorns than ever running in our pastures partly economic partly management.We are still in the Shorthorn business as one of the older breeders in Indiana and plan on being here longer than some new big spenders. We have recently started a set of Red Angus females and I LOVE THEM. Disposition is AWESOME. They perform at the feed pan. Lastly as a middle class adult I can afford them. Re world cattle do not cost more than my house.

I know you can not believe everything you are told, but I was recently told a very prominent steer family has $150,000 in three steers. Sorry Its just not that important to me and I have been at it my entire life!

Peace!
Jeff
 

trevorgreycattleco

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 22, 2010
Messages
2,070
Location
Centerburg, Ohio
So maybe we should compile a list of prospective bulls on here and have a vote and see which ones look to be the most useful to achieve what we need. With so many different enviroments to get input from, this could be cool. Not saying you have to use these bulls but it could help people choose. I think we should focus on bulls that make good mamas and grade well. Let the terminal cattle cross on ours in the commercial deal. The carcass is already there for the most part. We need easier calving bulls that still grow but not to much. Let the show heifer monopoly do it's thing. It is after all the cash cow of the association so why mess with it. This is another avenue to explore for the breed. A virtually untapped avenue IMO.
So do we start a new thread??? Or continue with this and add a poll? Thoughts? <beer>
 

sjcattleco

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 4, 2007
Messages
496
Location
Southeast Ohio
feeder duck said:
 Lets call an ace an ace. The Shorthorns are a 98% show ring breed. Until the entire breed grows  chasing the "big money" pedigrees and breeders go back to cutting there own path I am done. I have never been more frustrated by the "bull" in this breed than I am now. I am sure I speak for more than a few. There are some dam good low birth pedigreed cattle out there that will work.  Trying to sell Shorthorn heifers is a political nightmare. Enough Said!!!

 Jeff

Been hackin my way through Trump hell for 15 yrs!!! machete just keeps gettin sharper!!!!  figure more and more folks will just keep showin up!
 

aj

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 5, 2006
Messages
6,422
Location
western kansas
I don't know if jpj is the silver bullet. I think one of his sons might be. I do think the Shorthorn showring cattle are so far off the reservation that you have to start somewhere. I think the grandsons and grand daughters will be the movers and shakers. jpj is just a bb in a shotgun shell in my opinion. It would take a decade and probably 3 generations to breed the country club Shorthorns back to normal.jmo
 

oakbar

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 20, 2008
Messages
1,458
Location
North Central Iowa
You never know--there might even be a few "real world" shorthorns sold in Iowa this weekend.  In order to find them you might have to have more of an open mind than many who have posted on this thread, however. JMHO
 

justintime

Well-known member
Joined
May 26, 2007
Messages
4,346
Location
Saskatchewan Canada
oakbar said:
You never know--there might even be a few "real world" shorthorns sold in Iowa this weekend.   In order to find them you might have to have more of an open mind than many who have posted on this thread, however. JMHO

Thank you oakbar for those very wise words. I doubt if there are many breeders who run their cows on a more commercial basis than I do. I purchased 3 head last year in two of the sales that will be held this weekend. They have been run with our other cattle since arriving here, and they all calved unassisted, and have raised good calves on nothing but hay and grass ( a few salt blocks and mineral) Yes, these sales cater to the show ring crowd, but to say that there are no " real world" cattle being sold is totally wrong.  Study your lessons folks... and maybe we should all compliment a good animal when we see one regardless of it's pedigree or it's owner.I think the cattle business would be a much better place if we could do this.
 

Okotoks

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 17, 2010
Messages
3,085
oakbar said:
You never know--there might even be a few "real world" shorthorns sold in Iowa this weekend.   In order to find them you might have to have more of an open mind than many who have posted on this thread, however. JMHO
I'm sure there will be some useful animals in all these sales. Ones that will work for a lot of people. The old saying don't throw the baby out with the bath water. If we were to learn anything from the history of the breed it is that there are always good ones and more than most people think. Time and again a new trend comes along and really good cattle are discarded for not very good reasons. No animal is perfect and that's the fun and challenge, finding the next mating to get them to better fit our program and our customer's program. The animal you need could be in any of the fall sales but it would be pretty hard to find it if you have already discounted them. Some of the most successful animals in the history of the breed have been the blending of 2 or more bloodlines.
 

trevorgreycattleco

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 22, 2010
Messages
2,070
Location
Centerburg, Ohio
justintime said:
oakbar said:
You never know--there might even be a few "real world" shorthorns sold in Iowa this weekend.   In order to find them you might have to have more of an open mind than many who have posted on this thread, however. JMHO

Thank you oakbar for those very wise words. I doubt if there are many breeders who run their cows on a more commercial basis than I do. I purchased 3 head last year in two of the sales that will be held this weekend. They have been run with our other cattle since arriving here, and they all calved unassisted, and have raised good calves on nothing but hay and grass ( a few salt blocks and mineral) Yes, these sales cater to the show ring crowd, but to say that there are no " real world" cattle being sold is totally wrong.  Study your lessons folks... and maybe we should all compliment a good animal when we see one regardless of it's pedigree or it's owner.I think the cattle business would be a much better place if we could do this.

I have heard it all. To mock those that try and raise real world cattle. I have a news flash for you JIT. Feeding knee deep alfalfa all winter is not really testing your cattle. How long do your cows graze crop residue? Do you graze dormant forages and make them survive off it? I'm studying my lesson and I don't see one calf from sull I would buy. Sorry I don't need a show heifer that already has enough fat in her udder to hurt her milk production the rest of her life. JMO. Maybe I am missin the boat ,who knows. No hard feelings tho, just debate. To each their own.
 

Cowfarmer65

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Messages
201
Location
3060 South McNaughton Rd. Douglas, ON. Can.
Well said Dan and JIT.
Pedigree is not the be all and end all of good cattle. EPD's for that matter aren't either. I'm old school, I guess. I figure, if I have to look at the animal and feed it everyday, I better like what I'm lookin' at. My pedigrees may not have all the flashy names that have won all the accolades in the show ring, but most of those cattle if they had to get out and work with an everyday cow herd would fail miserably. Not all, but most.
I've spent my adult life working in the Construction industry and time and time again I'll get a set of blueprints for a mechanical system in a building or complex that looks really nice on paper but, there's no way in hell the system will ever work. The same holds true with cattle and pedigrees. JMO.
 

r.n.reed

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 29, 2008
Messages
611
I agree Dan that we should be careful not to throw the baby out with the bathwater.The breed has indeed made that mistake many times.However the commercial beef industry our judge and jury, has spoken loud and clear on our prominent genetics by the absense of Shorthorns in that arena.You can argue that no one has promoted them to that arena but I have to believe that if their was real or perceived value there ,true cattle businessmen would be utilizing them in their programs.
 

justintime

Well-known member
Joined
May 26, 2007
Messages
4,346
Location
Saskatchewan Canada
trevorgreycattleco said:
justintime said:
oakbar said:
You never know--there might even be a few "real world" shorthorns sold in Iowa this weekend.   In order to find them you might have to have more of an open mind than many who have posted on this thread, however. JMHO

Thank you oakbar for those very wise words. I doubt if there are many breeders who run their cows on a more commercial basis than I do. I purchased 3 head last year in two of the sales that will be held this weekend. They have been run with our other cattle since arriving here, and they all calved unassisted, and have raised good calves on nothing but hay and grass ( a few salt blocks and mineral) Yes, these sales cater to the show ring crowd, but to say that there are no " real world" cattle being sold is totally wrong.  Study your lessons folks... and maybe we should all compliment a good animal when we see one regardless of it's pedigree or it's owner.I think the cattle business would be a much better place if we could do this.

I have heard it all. To mock those that try and raise real world cattle. I have a news flash for you JIT. Feeding knee deep alfalfa all winter is not really testing your cattle. How long do your cows graze crop residue? Do you graze dormant forages and make them survive off it? I'm studying my lesson and I don't see one calf from sull I would buy. Sorry I don't need a show heifer that already has enough fat in her udder to hurt her milk production the rest of her life. JMO. Maybe I am missin the boat ,who knows. No hard feelings tho, just debate. To each their own.


TGCC... I was certainly not mocking you or anyone else, and I have no idea how you could even consider this. I would be one of the first people in line to commend anyone who tries to raise their cattle as economically with as little management as possible. I wish I had some crop residues to run my cows on but our farm is all in grass so my cows have to eat the dormant grass as long as the weather permits. This can vary from year to year, and we also have virtually no natural shelter from the wind, so this can affect when the cows come home. We have a few times been able to run the cows on the dead grass well into January.If we have had a drought, we have to start to feed earlier due to there being nothing left to graze. We have been wet this year, so I am hoping we can forage the cows well into December or later.

Once the cows start to be fed, I do make them walk. Unless it is bitter cold and windy, we feed them at least 1/2 mile from where they spend the night and water, so that they will walk at minimum 2 miles a day. Some days they walk further, some days the weather is just too cold and windy, so we have to feed closer to home. In any event, they have no shelter from wind and they have to go out and eat regardless of the weather. I believe cattle should only be tested if it is economical to do so. It is important that cows be able to flesh easily and be able to fend for themselves as long as possible. I think cows should have the ability to be tested on occasion, but I also believe that it is good management to look after your cows when they need it.

I was just saying, in my last post, that the bred heifers I purchased in these two sales were no fat when I purchased them. They have calved without assistance and have beautiful udders. They are rebred to calve in less than 365 days from calving this spring, and they have maintained their condition very well for having big strapping calves dragging on them all summer. The calves are still on them, and I plan to get them off early next week. We do feed some alfalfa as we can grow it in our area, but I will assure you that alfalfa is very poor feed if it is put up too mature or if it gets rained on. I actually do not like feeding alfalfa, as too often it is nothing more than coarse sticks. In our country, you often have only a few days to get alfalfa put up in good condition. If conditions are dry, the leaves will start to fall off it, a few days after it blossoms, and when we usually have over 1000 acres of hay to put up, we cannot get it all cut and baled when it should be done. Grass hay will wait for you longer.

In any event, I am just saying that there are some cattle from these outfits that can survive. I doubt if they all will, and that is why I said you have to study your lessons. You have to know the bloodlines, know the operation they come from, and know the cattle. Nothing more. If you don't do this, you can get harder doing cattle in most any sale.
 

sue

Well-known member
Joined
May 1, 2007
Messages
1,906
I took this picture of Muridale Buster 14K the summer after we purchased a flush on his dam, Robin.

Like if one could write better history about a bull - his sons and his daughters. Incredible bull with incredible breeders- hope you dont mind I posted my own photo of this bull.

Very few females have impressed me as much as Muridale Robin 57G. Time is ticking - scoop up this very proven sire.
 

Attachments

  • bustershrunk.jpg
    bustershrunk.jpg
    342.1 KB · Views: 188

Okotoks

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 17, 2010
Messages
3,085
trevorgreycattleco said:
aj said:
Trev in general I think you are right. However I think in the Shorthorn breed show ring deal you have to have tonner cows to compete. I think the the establishment is scared to death that if the breed decides to downsize they will be on the wrong end of the deal. I think this is why say jpj is badmouthed on here so bad cause he is such a down sizer. I do think a tonner cow can survive anywhere! All it takes is 30#'s of grain aday and 10 ton of alfalfa a year plus all the guru products.
The shorthorn show ring deal is as far from real world as you can get. Show cattle are for the most part hobby cattle and people don't pay attention to the bottom line as closely as a commercial guy because they don't have to.  I prefer the 5 frame cow that weighs between 1,200 and 1,500. IMO those type cattle will produce more profit per acre in my situation. JPJ is the latest attempt to fix a extreme with a extreme. Fire and ice. From now on when I look for females, one of the most important things to me is how they feed them. Do they work for themselves or are they pampered registered cattle.  Fescue is a pretty awesome thing when you learn how to use it and linebred cattle that have worked on it for years are the type I want to build from since I have tons of fescue! :eek: To bring in bulls from a A.I. pimp that are raised totally different than yours will take you backwards. How else can you explain the turnover rates  fact your cattle would thrive on fescue probably means they would work pretty well in my conditions, and you in the AI biz. Promotion, commotion, emotion lead to massive amounts of breeding mistakes. I know I have fallen for it in the past. My bulls being used now are not extreme in any way. The trick is having the guts and vision to use my own stuff for generations to build something better and bring in genetics(when needed) that will compliment not necessarily fix my herd. Sure sounds easy but we know better.
I agree with the approach that if you have tons of fescue you need cattle that convert it to pounds of beef most efficiently. I have traveled and visited a lot of purebred herds. In almost all cases they were being run in the same manner as the commercial herds in the same area. Usually in the fall the show cattle will be in on feed. At a rare few operations the show cattle are in for a few months. (our Agribition entries are still at pasture and the plan is to get them in this weekend, a little late for sure) We have sold our cattle into a lot environments and they have worked most places. The most difficult transition is often when they go to higher precipitation areas with softer grass, usually in those areas the breeders like to get them as calves or introduce new genetics through AI. When we sell our cattle into show program they have been known to get too fat. Look at the Saskvalley program, these cattle are run on a commercial basis with low inputs. Use their genetics and you are looking at show ring contenders. This is a Canadian perspective where we have a lot fewer shows and much shorter show season but if an animal can survive in a commercial type operation in one region there’s a good chance that animal or it’s offspring will survive in a lot of other conditions.The
cattle that thrive the best in your conditions are the ones that have the best chance in my operation. Now I'm going to have to bump Sue's post cause she is showing an example of the type that works in any environment!
 

Okotoks

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 17, 2010
Messages
3,085
sue said:
I took this picture of Muridale Buster 14K the summer after we purchased a flush on his dam, Robin.

Like if one could write better history about a bull - his sons and his daughters. Incredible bull with incredible breeders- hope you dont mind I posted my own photo of this bull.

Very few females have impressed me as much as Muridale Robin 57G. Time is ticking - scoop up this very proven sire.
Didn't want to bump Sue's post with this good bull so here it is again!
 

Attachments

  • bustershrunk.jpg
    bustershrunk.jpg
    342.1 KB · Views: 193
Top